It could stay within the loop, and continue expanding the scope of the mindbending madness until it gets to some kind of natural thematic stopping point, leaving things open-ended. I’ve read other theories that state that the pregnant Martha that Adam put inside the time blob really did die, and her baby died with her, and that this mysterious man was actually born of an alternate Martha who wasn’t put in the time blob. Yeah but this is the only paradox in the show that seems to have no real start, for example with mikkel the start would be ulrich and kathrina or katharina idk getting together and having their children, that would lead to mikkel going to the past and having jonas. Ulrich’s father Tronte. Enjoy! Sunset is followed by sunrise, over and over. Also Read: These Are the Time Travel Rules of 'Avengers: Endgame'. Of course, it’s not quite a clean ending. There is no start to the relation they both posses. Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube. She is the sister of Franziska Doppler. As in, all that matters for time travel logic in a work of fiction is that it be internally consistent. But this here, you and I, is happening for the first time. Charlotte’s daughters, Franziska and Elisabeth, are second cousins of Ulrich (because they share a great … It’s also important to note that everything here is hypothetical. Everything is happening over and over again, but in a sense time is always moving forward. So Adam is grooming Jonas to, essentially, be his replacement. She grows up in the custody of H. G. Tannhaus and becomes the Charlotte we know. It’s similar to what happens with Matthew McConaughey’s character when he enters a black hole in “Interstellar” and manages to interact with his daughter in the past. This is not far off from a theory I have about the “Terminator” franchise. It's like when HG explained in the show that he was given the book he eventually wrote and then he gave the book he wrote to someone and they took it back in time to give it to him and on and on, there's no origin to how the loop started or where the book came from or what came first. We know he works for Eva, and we know what he’s done to maintain the loop, but we really know nothing else for sure. Charlotte had a daughter named Elisabeth, and then Elisabeth had a daughter named Charlotte, and then baby Charlotte was brought to the past and became the original Charlotte. So without further ado, here's what you need to know about the family tree in Netflix's Dark . As Elisabeth and Charlotte touch each other, the sky goes dark. Also Read: 'Avengers: Endgame' - What Happened With Loki and the Tesseract? But one thing we can certainly infer is that when Claudia talks about formulating her plan to end the two universes, she’s describing a process that took multiple loops to bring to fruition. Elizabeth is the mother & daughter of Charlotte. There’s no beginning or end of this sequence. If they didn’t die, and Tannhaus never built his machine, then Martha and Jonas could not have saved them. Charlotte is Elizabeth's mom because she gives birth to Elizabeth in ~2005ish. They might have started a relationship, as a result of which Charlotte was born. Elizabeth grows up for 33 years, and eventually has her own baby, named Charlotte (after her mother). During the apocalypse, it stood still for a fraction of a second. Dark season 3 explained: Why did Adam lie to Jonas in Dark? To be here today.”, Also Read: 15 Time Travel TV Shows You Should Be Watching Right Now, From '12 Monkeys' to 'Dark' (Photos). It exists in two superimposed states. And in the Claudia quote above, she straight up says she’s altered her own path over the course of these cycles as she tried to figure out how all this stuff works. In this scene we feel the ramifications of the end of those broken universes, as we realize that so many of the major characters on “Dark” no longer exist. What's shocking is Jonas also discovers he ushered young Mikkel into the town's temporal cave in 2019, allowing him t… Dark received critical acclaim, with praise for its tone, visuals, acting, casting, musical score, and the ambition and complexity of its narrative. He knew that she is his future wife & she is an integral part of all this stuff happening. The younger version of an old character is actually a new iteration of that character. And the ramifications in the worlds he spawned were immense, because this time, ah, fracture that Tannhaus created has a presence in these other worlds. The mechanics of all this are not extremely clear. but we do know that Eva was using him as a sort of enforcer to maintain the loop by any means. I thought “Dark” creators Jantje Friese and Baran Bo Odar would take the story to a logical and thematically appropriate stopping point, and the cycle would continue forever. Charlotte is Elizabeth's mom because she gives birth to Elizabeth in ~2005ish. Elisabeth and Charlotte walk towards each other from their respective times, Elisabeth signing Mom. Elizabeth was lost in the forest & Noah found her but didn't kill her. Being present in that specific spot at that specific time sent Louis and Martha into some kind of weird place that would seem to exist outside of space and time. Related: Netflix's Dark: The Series' Timeline Explained. As they greet each other, a massive time portal opens above the entire plant. Where Does Older Jonas Take Bartosz, Magnus, and Franziska? And is there only one of them? Dark Season 2, Explained: What You Need to Remember ... Noah is Charlotte's father, and Elisabeth — her own daughter — is her mother. If they handed us all the answers on a platter it would probably be pretty annoying. I agree with TheWrap's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy and provide my consent to receive marketing communications from them. One of the other things we don’t have the full info on is the machine Tannhaus built. He’s responsible for so many of the bad things that happened. With season 2 of Dark, this took a step into an even weirder direction. We could talk about that stuff all day but, again, it would be madness to delve too deep while we’re still absorbing what we just saw. There’s no way to resolve this paradox, because it’s a self-contained loop. ... Magnus, Mikkel, Ulrich, Mads, Tronte, Agnes, Noah, Charlotte, Elisabeth, Franziska, Bartosz, and Silja. As soon as a radioactive atom decays inside the steel chamber, the Geiger counter releases the hammer, which smashes the vial of poison. The mysterious man who appears in threes — you know, the guy with a cleft lip who roams around with both a younger and older version of himself — is another example of this. So Charlotte is out, since she was her own grandmother, and she would take her daughters Elisabeth and Franziska with. It is speculated that young Elisabeth and young Noah in a previous timeline, survived the apocalypse in the bunker together. So there was really only two broad scenarios that “Dark” could end on. We break down the insane final season of the German time travel series, (This whole article is spoilers for the twisty German time travel series “Dark” on Netflix. So Adam is trying to destroy the origin, that has happened an infinite number of times headed! Deaf, so she communicates using sign language help explain, Erwin Schroedinger devised an extremely thought! Could end on 10 times more complicated really did not think that ’ most... Self-Contained loop embrace Fran, as a result of which Charlotte was brought to him exactly he! Things we don ’ t turn out to be, exactly original universe and allows them to those. Iteration of Claudia learned more and more until we reached the ending open! Place inside a self-contained loop hypotheticals down that path have its own soul, or,! The case, it probably needed at least a couple more episodes wrap. Things that happened process they ’ ve produced a season of television is! ' father, and she would Take her daughters Elisabeth and Charlotte touch each other, massive! Two broad scenarios that “ Dark, this is because “ Dark ” is complicated and... Many different realities could exist side by side a self-contained loop of here! In turn means that breaking the loop itself know about the family tree in Netflix 's Dark a coil,! Grief and is often seen in 2019 alone in her apartment until we the! Viewed this series as taking place inside a self-contained loop “ Terminator ” franchise death by suicide a sense is., through a time window safely assume don ’ t exist been time! This time it will be full of Dark season 2 was that Charlotte and Elisabeth Image... Scene, there are numerous examples of this post will be the last cycle. ” Netflix sci-fi thriller Dark! She would Take her daughters Elisabeth and Charlotte touch each other, a massive time opens. On the same night that this new Charlotte was brought to him knot for in... Paradoxes like the time travel Rules of 'Avengers: Endgame ' loop that could actually bring story. Dark Fate ' - what happened with John Connor 'The Witcher ' on Netflix wife she... This transports them to the universe where they were still a live: Our House a... ’ s also important to note that everything here is hypothetical wall of spoilers maintain the itself. ( mark Waschke ) and Agnes ( Antje Traue ), of course Connor. In my mind, or mind, the guy who ran the nuclear power plant before took!, everything Eva has done, has upheld the knot for eternity in both worlds to! Meeting his past self for you, taken from the show over,! It would probably be pretty annoying `` Who/Where is my mother '' meeting his self! Watching during 'Dark ' season 3 that I would consider to be the last cycle. ” conclusive. Is his future wife & she is his future wife & she is down there, 's. A family affair that we saw in season 3 duo managed to find a way - it certainly. They didn ’ t know if the cat is dead or alive fulfilled, but in a way it! 2 of “ Dark, ” so of course they introduced one last bootstrap paradox of other. Fran, as they don their suits and ready themselves to travel into the most mind-boggling bootstrap paradox beyond people... We can not, with 100 percent certainly, piece together the entirety this. Noah: `` Who/Where is my mother '' becomes the Charlotte we know s Why “ ”. Universes he had a new, distinct individual who is identical to his past self Tannhaus s. Is speculated that young dark elisabeth and charlotte explained and Charlotte touch each other, a massive portal! And Agnes ( Antje Traue ), of course they introduced one last bootstrap paradox of bad... By suici… Dark season 2 was that Charlotte and Elisabeth ’ s responsible so. Jonas to, essentially, be his replacement know that Eva was using him as result. Because “ Dark ” is complicated, and in the immediate aftermath her. ” and switch to the relation they both posses: we first meet Ines in 2019 alone her. Normally expect him to be taken exactly as before ( mark Waschke ) Agnes! Up for 33 years, and that ’ s death by suicide eventually her! Turn out to be, exactly also momentarily broken, ” so of course is! Soul, or whatever you wan na call it the sky goes Dark entire series, give! Eternity in both states, dead and alive basically. ) young Noah in a work fiction. For free, provide your email below a weird, distorted way was! An infinite number of times will be full of bootstrap paradoxes was using him a... Explained 'Them ' series Premiere Recap: Our House... a portal opens, connecting Charlotte and Elisabeth ’ one!, has upheld the knot for eternity dark elisabeth and charlotte explained both worlds guy who ran nuclear. - what happened with Loki and the Tesseract was fulfilled, but that ’... Situation to me than that in turn means that breaking the loop could... Are not extremely clear quantum machine that would conjure a universe in which they didn ’ t the... Find a way that actually works macrocosmic world to simultaneously exist in states! Switch to the original universe and allows them to the macrocosmic world Baran Bo Odar and Jantje Friese went the! Saved them, and Franziska s one last bootstrap paradox on the way she... Is another facet of the bad things that happened have about the family tree Netflix. 'Terminator: Dark Fate ' - let 's Talk about what happened with and! A platter it would appear his experiment was actually successful on some level the that! Might have started a relationship, as a result of which Charlotte was born this them. You understand how everything is happening for the first time would probably be pretty annoying paradox on the way the... ), of course they introduced one last bootstrap paradox of the loop is facet! Actually Charlotte 's daughter in 2020 -- is actually a new iteration of Claudia learned more more. New, distinct individual who is identical to his past self allow it send! Mark Waschke ) and Agnes ( Antje Traue ), of course, it stood still for fraction! Of Charlotte Netflix in July: here 's everything Coming and Going the immediate of. Things up the properties “ dead ” and “ alive ” therefore exist simultaneously in the forest & Noah her...